Characteristic | Nozzle | Packed Bed | Tray Tower | Venturi |
Operation Principle | Uses nozzles to spray the cleaning solution onto contaminated stream. | Passes polluted air through a packed layer of material (usually balls, rings, or blocks) to contact the cleaning solution. | Gas passes through vertically arranged trays or pans with the cleaning solution, providing multiple contact surfaces. | Gas accelerates through a converging-diverging nozzle where it meets cleaning fluid, creating intense gas-liquid interaction. |
Cleaning Efficiency | Provides good mixing of air and solutions, improving cleaning performance. | Provides effective contact between gases and the cleaning solution but may have limited contact surface. | Provides effective contact through the formation of a bubbling layer (foam) on the tray surfaces, which can lead to high purification. | Very high efficiency for particulate removal and fine aerosol control due to high gas velocity and liquid droplet shearing. |
Applications | Often used in situations where precise control of solution spraying is required. | Used for removing contaminants with a high concentration of gaseous components. | Widely used in industries for processing streams with various types of contaminants and is effective with dust. | Ideal for high-velocity exhausts, fine particulate removal, and handling high air flows. Works well with aerosol control. |
Advantages | Provides precise control over spraying and solution flow. Lowest aerodynamic resistance, leading to minimal energy consumption. | Provides high purification due to a large surface area for gas-liquid contact. | Effective when working with air containing solid particles. | Compact design, very efficient for particulate and aerosol removal, low maintenance. |
Disadvantages | The fastest reaction rate between phases results in lower efficiency, or if a high level of purification is required, the unit size must be increased. | May be more prone to clogging of the packing material (media) if there is a dust load. However, it is the most effective unit for gas cleaning. | Higher aerodynamic resistance compared to other units. It is difficult to calculate acid scrubber efficiency due to the specific nature of the gas exchange processes. | High energy consumption due to gas acceleration. Requires additional equipment for droplet separation. |